>>24056
>Unlike Knuckles, Amy (much like Sonic & Tails) is a character that can be plugged into any story they see fit without having to account for things like Angel Island, or the Master Emerald whereas Knuckles has always needed an excuse to get off the island & join Sonic in his adventures, at least until the mid-late 2000s.
>Sonic Heroes was 18 years ago
Time flies, doesn't it? Heroes was much closer to Sonic 1 than it is to now. Also, it isn't as if the Archie comics, with the same writer, didn't already have excuses to just have other people watch the Emerald. And it isn't as if Forces isn't the most recent game and the one the current comics directly reference all the time.
>Which they have for years, with at least half of Post-Reboot Sonic Universe having arcs that focused on either Knuckles or Shadow.
Well that's just not true. There are four arcs about them and seven not about them.
>Amy isn't the kind of character that has lore to take into account when it comes to using her in a story, since she'll follow Sonic around wherever he goes, much like Tails.
Except when she becomes leader of The Resistance, for some reason. Quite far outside her normal character.
>It's also the reason why you're less likely to see a full arc centered around her as the star protag, because she has always been more of a support character to Sonic
But there are arcs about her, or at least about small groups that include her, but they all just amount to girl power team arcs, instead of cool shit that could be done with her. Use her tarot cards or something, dang. More could be done with Amy instead of just making her a "tough girl" which is very far from her game persona, and is cliche as hell anyway. Yes, there are even more exaggerated versions of that cliche, but that doesn't make it particularly good here.
>as opposed to Knuckles, who's always done his own thing but gets wrapped up in Sonic's shit.
More like Sonic does his own thing and gets rapped up in Knuckles' shit. Knuckles is connected to the main macguffins of the series, while Sonic doesn't give a shit and just gets wrapped up in things.
I understand the arguments about The Resistance and its leaders, but it's really irrelevant to the point when you're talking about fictional stories being created from near scratch. Frankly, the entire Resistance shit went on way too long and should have been wrapped up a long time ago, given that Forces didn't even have a good story to begin with. The first arc being about the fallout of Forces is a fine idea, but after that, come the fuck on. Beyond that, they can come up with any reason they want to have Knuckles around, and if the game didn't do that, then that's precisely what the comics should have done right away. The comics should have given Knuckles a reason to be around, which could retroactively apply to the game, in the first or second issue.
>they more or less appealed to those complaints with Amy taking over, at least until people started complaining about Amy leading the group made her Sally 2.0, so they gave the spot to Jewel, who otherwise had nothing going on for her after the Whisper & Tangle arc.
They appealed to those complaints in the wrong way. Making Amy Sally 2.0 isn't a solution, and making Jewel Sally 3.0 is even worse. Jewel didn't have anything to do? Yeah, she's an OC. She shouldn't have very much to do. They should focus on the characters from the source, roughly in their level of importance in the source material. They don't need a Sally, and especially not one that isn't the actual Sally anyway. They shouldn't just invent new OCs to replace the ones they aren't allowed to use anymore.
>Hate to be that guy, but the comics has had Amy be pretty active for a long time now, dating back to late Pre-Reboot Archie.
Yes, I referenced that.
>And her character becoming "stronger & more competent over time" is a narrative that even SEGA has started pushing,
Yes, but the comics don't handle it well. See the difference between her arc in Adventure, which is simple but well done, and how she subsequently acts in Heroes and '06 (and SA2 and Shadow, but she isn't as important in those), to how she acts in the comics.
>IDW is just putting her more in line with all of this, as opposed to just throwing her on the side again
IDW is not doing that, at least not well. And the alternative would not be throwing her on the side, it would be writing her to be more like the games.
>As for the new OCs that are aligned with the good guys being female, that mostly comes down to Sonic not having a female cast as large as the male cast.
So that means not only that OCs should be female, but that they should all be good and any male ones should all be bad?
>Hell it's why we're probably gonna be seeing more new villains in IDW show up, since the Rogue's Gallery for Sonic (even with the additions of Mimic, Starline & Rough & Tumble) are extremely limited, outside of Eggman, Metal Sonic & the Deadly Six.
And the Battle Kukkus. And Witchcart and her minions. And Fang. And Bean and Bark. And the Black Arms. And Mephiles. And didn't they even use Breezie after the Super Genesis Wave? I wonder if they can still use AoStH characters at all, since they could use her. In fact, she should have been the one doing the Chao stuff in that recent arc, instead of that OC. And if you're counting Metal Sonic as his own character and not just an Eggman minion, then you can count the other Sonic robots, including the one from 3&K who seemed to be acting on his own and is the main bad guy in Knuckles' story.
Also, when you're saying Sonic's female cast is not as large as its male cast, I call bullshit, at least if you're counting more major characters. Major male characters include Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, Eggman, and Shadow. They haven't been using many of the male characters beyond that. I guess Big if you want to count him. Major female characters include Amy, Rouge, Cream, and Blaze. They could also use characters like Marine or even Sticks if they wanted, probably. Oh and there are the babylon rogues, 1/3 female. They could use Witchcart and probably Breezie but they don't. One of Witchcart's main minions is female, and she only has like three minions right? I might be forgetting some characters, both male and female, but my point is that there are plenty to use.
>And given that this team is mostly the same group of people that worked on Archie Sonic which gave us evil Fiona Fox, Sonar, Conquering Storm & Thunderbolt, as well as bringing back Wendy Witchcart, we're likely due for some new female villains soon.
Look, I wouldn't be noticing things like this if it wasn't CY+6 and if the creators weren't sperging out on twitter about their extremist politics in the first place. But since they do, and since the comics industry in general is so fucked, then I start to notice all these other things which, in isolation, I might otherwise ignore.