>>986479
It has some positives, and if there are fixes to the most glaring flaws of current job balance (DRK MP loss, braindead monk, BLM having 0 flexibility, etc...) it could be the best FFXIV has been in a couple years, but only really gameplay wise.
And there is a lot of neat lore. They didn't fuck up the lore, I guess one of the old writers was on standby to make sure that specifically didn't happen. Zones are beautiful and I really like the 5th zone. I hate the 6th zone, though, and I'm not sure how they're going to address the fact that (lvl 100 msq spoiler)
it has zero content because we turned off its entire populace. 4 sidequests aside from aether current quests. What the fuck. Its a literal dead grey zone sparse of everything, including fates.
It has kernels of good in there, legitimate good questions being asked, but the writing is so atrocious that none of it is addressed in a decent way. All the character moments especially in that section of the game is marred by this... and Wuk Lamat.
If you want a good comparison, Wuk Lamat is basically pre-Crystal Braves Alphinaud. Except she gets vindicated time after time again, and Alphinaud has exactly 0 character moments discussing her flaws and making her a more mature character. Similar deal with Koana, a character you meet early on, is clearly "the smart one" and Wuk Lamat is similar to early Alisae in that she feels inferior towards him and her other brother. But does Alisae pull Wuk Lamat to the side and express the lessons/character development that she personally got in that regard? No, because the Twins get one obligatory dialogue per zone to remind you that they're there.
Someone posted a word count of all the characters in Dawntrail and it is hilariously dominated by Wuk Lamat. I only wish Wuk Lamat was an actually interesting character to warrant that word count. This could have worked, but the guy who wrote this expansion WAS the same dude who did the post 6.0 story. He also did the Werlyt trial series which was well written so I'm not sure what the hell this guy is doing.
Arguably all these issues would have also been less of a problem if the pacing wasn't god awful. CBU3 has been having pacing issues in all of their games as of late though. It could be this dipshit writer, it could also be a higher up at Squeenix being retarded (many such cases.)
This is just Stormblood all over again, except with shittier job design. If you're in it for the fights, I'd just skip all 90-95 MSQ scenes except the Yok Huey stuff (level 93) and the lizard fuck stuff (level 95), i.e. the best parts of the 90-95 stuff. You miss actually nothing until you get to Shaaloni, the best part of the expansion.
I played through the extra release dungeons, and they're all really solid. Trash packs actually have threats in them now. The last trash pack in the
Halloween dungeon has an actual soft enrage, too.