>>1079537
Meh, not canon to the games, so regardless of it's quality not much skin off my back.
Anyway I ended up doing two little write-ups today by chance, on the Main Characters from two of my favorite games, so might as well post them here.
First, what people get wrong about Dante.
The transition from DMC3 to DMC4 is the real core of the issue.
DMC4 Dante is an older version of DMC3 Dante, but he doesn't feel like DMC1 Dante who already IS the older version of DMC3 Dante. Without jumping through hoops to rationalize the obvious decision that they just copied DMC3 Dante because he was popular. DMC4 Dante comes off as a character regression in terms of Dante's development. Now, DMC4 Dante is far from bad, but DMC1 Dante is clearly a more Heroic acting person. DMC1 Dante is willing to put his foot down, and call out villainy, and state his convictions. You can say Dante is only acting this way because DMC1 was some serious shit for him, but that's coping. DMC1 is The Original Dante, all the others versions need to accommodate his seniority because they only exist because of him, not the other way around. DMC4 Dante acts as if he doesn't care, and while he does care, and he is a good person deep down, DMC1 Dante wasn't afraid to let it be known he's the Hero when the chips were down. People will say DMC1 Dante did some Cringe stuff, yeah so what? That means the character had Sincerity to him, DMC1 Dante doesn't give a fuck what others think about him, He's the successor to The Legendary Dark Knight title. Not "The Legendary Devil Hunter" that DMC4 or DMC5 Dante is. DMC1 Dante is the LDK like his father before him. He's not the "Wacky Wahoo Pizza Man", He's the guy that will stare Satan in the face and say "Come out and fight like a man"
The Core of Ryu Hayabusa
NG1 is very important to understanding what makes Ryu so strong. Ryu's death is an important factor. Ryu totally died, he wasn't near death, he didn't focus his ki to survive, he wasn't saved in the nick of time, he was a decaying Corpse, just like every other Hayabusa who died that day. But Ryu didn't get to rest with his clan. Ryu was choosen by the Spirit of the Falcon in which the Hayabusa clan is named after. By THE Hayabusa to be given a 2nd chance. For one simple reason. Vengeance. Ryu is only alive to this day for the purpose of killing people who have it coming. That was Specifically what he was chosen to do. He's not a normal human regardless of the Dragon Ninja clan blood in his veins. He is an Instrument of a gods will.
Adding more here to what I already had above.
Vengeance is a big part of what makes both Dante and Ryu who they are, and a problem nowadays is modern Writers are pussies who refuse to let Heroes be Heroic, without undercutting in some way. DMC3 Dante had to be undercut at times because he was still too young and cocky to be a hero, but by the end of that game he learned what his purpose in life was, to help people, not just work for the highest bidder. That part of Dante is still around to a degree, but it's not showcased well, because we never see anyone test Dante, they never try and tempt him, which will can be used to display he is Uncorruptible.
The entire song Subhuman in DMC5 kind of goes against this idea, because it implies Dante always has an internal struggle with his Super Human Demonic nature that he needs to always remind himself that he's human, he should have dealt with that shit when he was 18, not nearing his 40s. That was the entire point of DMC3 was Dante accepting both his Humanity and Demonic side as one. Devil May Cry 3 "Dante's Awakening" is Dante's true character being "Awakened" fucking Duh.
Now Ryu it's much less complicated, everyone already knows NG3 was poorly written, it was a game that attempted to Humanize Ryu, but not in a way that actually made sense for his character. NG3 Ryu comes off as younger and less experienced than he did in NG1. This stems from the fact NG3 was written by Masato Kato, who was a big force behind the stories for the NES Ninja Gaiden games, but Modren Ryu is a hole other beast then NES Ryu. NES Ryu was a very Emotional character, that's part of where all the drama of those NES cutscenes came from they impressed back in the day because there was an actual plot that existed in a Coherent and Thought out, but NG3 was not thought out in terms of it being a continuation of the two prior games.
Masato Kato basically picked up where he left off, doing little to understand what the Ryu he was actually working with was, NG3 Ryu slips back to that NES Ryu in plenty of ways, where most mistakes NG3 Ryu makes In the narrative, That Modren Ryu should have never fell for. The Relationship between Ryu and Canna didn't need to be flawed, but it results in Ryu fumbling his Composure, and not really doing anything impressive in NG3 aside from Generic ninja action, that we already know he can do. The real missing part of Ryu in NG3 is that there is none of that wise sage nature he displayed ever so slightly in NG2, the most interesting part of that entire game's script, was Ryu spitting some subtle wisdom, that showed the Greater Fiends, didn't have shit on him. NG3 Ryu should have said some genuinely Intelligent things, if they wanted to humanize him, show he's more than just a walking death machine, he has an Appreciation for the little things in life as well, it would be a call back to the fact DOA1 Ryu owned and ran an Antique shop. Ryu probably has more in common interests with Muramasa than he does anyone else. Show Ryu casually hanging out with the old man if you want to see his Human side, Ryu might actually be very interested in what Muramasa has to say, given he knew about the True Power of the Dragon Sword, and Ryu didn't in NG1. "Perhaps Joe Hayabusa knew, but he hadn't told Ryu as Joe hadn't officially passed down the sword to Ryu in NG1, he was just having Ryu watch over it for a time" Over all NG3 Ryu lacks some of the competency that he clearly displayed in the two prior games. I guess you can blame everything on the grip of murder curse and sweep it all under the rug.
So called Professional Writers need to do their fucking homework, but eh, fat chance that shits gonna change.