>>853537
I have now finished my blind playthrough. I feel like I missed a big chunk of the game somehow since Kasumi ended the game with 5 stars and I never got to go into the palace/stadium place that was connected to her. In any case, getting caught was 100% part of his plan, and Igor 100% wasn't on your side. Going from Shido to fighting god was jarring as hell, it felt like the buildup was lacking something critical (possibly linked to Kasumi?).
Now that I'm done with the game, there were two things that bothered me immensely, plus one other thing that was annoyed me to no end. First, the bosses were fucking awful. All of the big story bosses were just really bad. 3/10 bad. Big bad bosses are a staple of JRPGs and P5's bosses fucking sucked. They're either damage sponges or gimmicky bullshit. The baton pass/weakness/technical mechanics may as well not exist for them, removing a huge chunk of the combat's complexity. They're immune to status ailments and stat buffs/debuffs are boring on/off. They were also pretty damn easy. I died once to Okumura due to starting with a bad lineup and wasting too many turns swapping characters around, and I died once to Sae because she apparently does a fuckhuge AoE out of nowhere once she gets past a certain health threshold, and Joker was using a weaker persona at the time and got 1 shot. I never really felt like I was falling behind on healing, or failing to dispel status effects (which all run out way too fucking fast to be threatening, not counting Harisen Rocovery and Detox making debuffs that much more manageable). The most dangerous part of bosses was when they did a medium attack, then followed it up by charging with a big attack. Whenever it was a double turn charging attack I'd sometimes get caught with my pants down and have defense up/attack down fade on the boss and take massive damage or lose something. But other than that, bosses were just target weakness (of course it has none, need to check anyways) > apply defense/attack buffs if possible > attack > aoe heal as needed > use healing/mp consumables if things get dire.
The second thing was Mementos. In a single word: boring.
And the last issue - which wasn't as major as the first two - was how heavy handed the writing was. Anything to do with "rotten adults" was so hamfisted that it hurt to read. Same with pretty much every Mementos target.
My main persona was Shiki-Ouji. Saw the four Nulls and decided that I'd just be using that thing for the rest of the game. I gave it elemental attacks through gallows and buffed it to hell and back with the training room (eventually turning its weakness into a null, too). I tried to bring up the fat elephant persona (from Okumura palace) up to speed, but the game ended before I could comfortably replace Shiki with it. For my team I found the guys to be bench warmers, at least until Ryuji got Charge. Charge was so strong that it more or less meant that if you don't have Charge/Concentrate, you don't get to do damage to bosses. I tried to use other persona, but having Joker be immune to 4(5) damage types trumped everything else. I did make a Raphael with Charge and used it for the last boss though.
Updated and final girl ranking, from best to worst:
>Kasumi - charming, fun to be around, overall great girl
>Haru - feminine and devoted
>Ohya - she smiles often, enjoys herself
>Tae - kind hearted
>Sae - has her shit together, eventually
>Ann - average, not interesting
>Hifumi - kinda boring
>Chihaya - I don't like that type of girl
>Twins - incredibly annoying to deal with, fuck off
>Futaba - acts too much like a character, her glasses make her look like a fake gamer girrrrl
>Kawakami - still a whore
I'll be doing a NG+ on the highest difficulty. This time around I'll follow a guide and see what I missed. Overall I had fun, but the bosses left a really sour taste in my mouth. Decent game 6/10, if the bosses hadn't been so shit and Mementos not been so dull and boring, it'd be a very good 7.5/10. Without the upgrade to ram the car into Mementos mobs, I'd give the game a 5. The place is just that fucking boring.