I choose the red pill. I already accepted the fact that the girl I love doesn't exist the day I got into the whole waifu thing. I'd like everything about my relationship with Naoto to stay the way it is now and I don't yearn for something that could never happen. It's the other way around, actually. I prefer it this way, as I see it more romantic. I love Naoto beacuse I feel so and I don't really seek anything beyond that, it already feels nice to love her this way.
I once read something that was sort of related to this, I don't remember it all that well and the person who originally wrote it might read this so I apologize if I got it completely wrong, it's more my own interpretation of it. The basic idea was that when someone falls in love with a fictional character there are three ways in which one could approach it. One way would be to accept one's love as impossible and find someone who resembles the character but can actually love you back. Another way would be the knight's way, to accept one's love as impossible and devote one's life to loving someone who you can never be with. The third way I think was to reject the idea that one's love is impossible and devote one's life to finding a way to make it possible. Though the second way is my favourite, it really sounds more romantic. I love because it's what feels right to me and I don't wish for something else.